What Are The Negatives Of Above Ground Pools?
Thought getting an above ground pool would be all fun and floaties?
We get it — they do look like a no-brainer on a sunny afternoon. Cheaper, easier to set up, and you’re paddling in no time.
And honestly, they can be exactly that — as long as you know what to expect.
Here’s the truth: above ground pools are a brilliant choice for summer fun, but they come with a few things to think through. From styling to setup, maintenance to materials — it’s all manageable, as long as you’re in the know.
So if you’re weighing up the splash vs. the setup, this guide’s for you.
Understanding the Disadvantages of Above Ground Pools
Aesthetic Limitations
"Tacky" Perception and Visual Dominance
Above ground pools might not scream luxury right out of the box — but with a bit of planning, they don’t have to look out of place.
Yes, they’re big and bold. But bold can be beautiful when paired with clever landscaping, neat decking, or even simple screens or planting.
It’s all about vision. With the right touches, you can go from “eyesore” to “eye-catching” in a weekend.
Difficulty Blending into Landscaping Without Effort
It’s true — if you plonk it in the middle of your lawn and call it done, it might look out of place.
But here’s the good news: above ground pools are perfect for creative landscaping. Think raised decking, pergolas, trellises, or timber enclosures. Even just levelling off the ground or adding a border of stones can transform the look.
Yes, it takes a little effort — but the results speak for themselves.
Less Customisable in Shape and Depth
Above ground pools tend to come in standard sizes and shapes, usually round or rectangular.
That said, there’s now more variety than ever — especially with premium ranges offering larger models, built-in seating, or sleeker styling.
And for most families, the standard depths are ideal for splashing, lounging, and safe fun for kids.
Durability and Lifespan Concerns
Susceptibility to Punctures or Damage (liners)
Vinyl liners can be punctured, it’s true — but with proper care, this is easy to avoid.
Keep sharp toys and tools away, check your setup regularly, and consider a protective groundsheet or foam base. Many kits even include patch kits for peace of mind.
With just a little maintenance, your liner can last for years.
Material Degradation Over Time (fading, rust, wear)
Like anything outdoors, above ground pools face the elements. But most models are built to handle sun, rain, and temperature swings.
Modern pools use rust-resistant frames, UV-stable materials, and reinforced linings. A pool cover and the odd checkup go a long way.
Look after it, and it’ll reward you with seasons of reliable fun.
Potential for Collapse (if not properly maintained/installed)
Proper setup is everything. A level base, following the manual, and double-checking fixings makes all the difference.
The good news? Once it’s in and stable, there’s very little risk. Most collapses come from poor installation — not the product itself.
So take your time, follow the instructions, and don’t cut corners. Safe, solid, splash-ready.
Practical Challenges and Maintenance Considerations
Access and Usage Limitations
Ladder-Only Entry/Exit (less graceful entry than steps)
Most above ground pools come with ladders — and while they’re simple, they do the job well.
Want more comfort or accessibility? You can easily upgrade to wide-step ladders or even build a small deck platform for that “walk-in” feel.
There are loads of clever solutions available, even for small spaces.
Limited Deep Ends for Diving
Above ground pools aren’t made for diving — and that’s okay. They shine as safe, shallow spaces perfect for families, floaties, and lazy lounging.
If you're after fitness or laps, look for longer rectangular models. And if it’s fun you want? Trust us — there’s plenty of that to go around.
Potential for Heat Loss (especially exposed walls)
Because they’re not buried like in-ground pools, heat can escape faster.
But that’s easy to manage: use a quality solar cover, consider a pool heater if you want extra warmth, and position your pool in a sunny spot if possible.
With just a few tweaks, you can keep the water feeling glorious.
Maintenance and Upkeep Demands
Routine Cleaning and Chemical Balancing
It’s true — pools need care. But once you’ve got your routine down, it’s a breeze.
Test strips, a simple chemical kit, and a few minutes each week is all it takes. Think of it like brushing your teeth — regular little jobs that keep everything fresh and healthy.
Vulnerability to Debris and Algae Growth
Leaves and insects love open water — but they don’t have to stick around.
A quality cover, a skimmer net, and a decent filter system will do most of the heavy lifting. Want to go hands-free? Consider a robotic cleaner and put your feet up.
Winterisation Requirements
UK winters can be rough — but prepping your pool is easier than it sounds.
Drain where needed, protect your fittings, and use a strong winter cover. That’s it. Come spring, you’ll be set to go without major repairs or mess.
Resale Value and Perceived Value
Impact on Property Value
Above ground pools don’t usually add value like an in-ground one might — but they don’t have to be a downside either.
They’re removable, affordable, and not a permanent change. And for some buyers, a garden that screams “family fun” is a bonus.
Cost of Removal for Future Homeowners
If a future buyer doesn’t want it, removal is straightforward. No concrete, no plumbing — just disassemble, reseed the grass, and you’re done.
Compared to an in-ground option, that flexibility can actually be a plus.
Comparison to In-Ground Pools
Less "Luxury" Appeal
In-ground pools definitely carry that high-end look. But above ground pools win on practicality, budget-friendliness, and flexibility.
Add decking, lighting, or a few garden features — and you’ll be surprised how sleek an above ground setup can feel.
Perceived as a Temporary Solution
Yes — and for many families, that’s part of the appeal.
They’re ideal for growing families, rental homes, or anyone who wants a splash zone without the commitment or cost of a permanent install.
Final Thoughts: Is an Above Ground Pool Right for Your Garden?
We’re all for poolside fun — but we’re even more for helping you make a smart choice.
Above ground pools offer amazing value, safe family fun, and the freedom to install without digging up your garden.
They’re not perfect — no pool is. But with a bit of know-how and care, they can be a brilliant summer solution that looks great and lasts.
So if you’re dreaming of garden splash days, floaty unicorns, and cooling off on hot afternoons — this could be your best move yet.
Just know what you’re getting into... and then dive in.
Have you checked out our other posts?
Can Above Ground Pools Look Nice?
Is It Worth Buying An Above Ground Pool?
Above Ground Pools That Look Like Inground
Leave a comment